Project

General

Profile

Actions
History

Wiki » Proposals »

Containers API » History » Revision 8

« Previous | Revision 8/64 (diff) | Next »
Tom Clegg, 06/04/2015 05:58 PM

Jobs API (DRAFT)

Clients control JobRequests. The system controls Jobs, and assigns them to JobRequests. When the system has assigned a Job to a JobRequest, anyone with permission to read the JobRequest also has permission to read the Job.

A JobRequest describes job constraints which can have different interpretations over time. For example, a JobRequest with {"git_revision":"abc123..master"} might be satisfiable by any of several different source trees, and this set of satisfying source trees changes whenever the repository's "master" branch is updated.

A Job is an unambiguously specified process. Git revisions, data collections, docker images, etc. are specified using content addresses. A Job serves as a statement of exactly what computation will be attempted and, later, a record of what computation was done.

JobRequest/Job life cycle

Illustrating job re-use and preview facility:
  1. Client CA creates a JobRequest JRA with priority=0.
  2. Server creates job JX and assigns JX to JRA, but does not try to run JX yet because max(priority)=0.
  3. Client CA presents JX to the user. "We haven't computed this result yet, so we'll have to run a new job. Is this OK?"
  4. Client CB creates a JobRequest JRB with priority=1.
  5. Server assigns JX to JRB and puts JX in the execution queue with priority=1.
  6. Client CA updates JRA with priority=2.
  7. Server updates JX with priority=2.
  8. Job JX starts.
  9. Client CA updates JRA with priority=0. (This is the "cancel" operation.)
  10. Server updates JX with priority=1. (JRB still wants this job to complete.)
  11. Job JX finishes.
  12. Clients CA and CB have permission to read JX (ever since JX was assigned to their respective JobRequests) as well as its progress indicators, output, and log.

"JobRequest" schema

Attribute Type Description Discussion Examples
uuid, owner_uuid, modified_by_client_uuid, modified_by_user_uuid string Usual Arvados model attributes
created_at, modified_at datetime Usual Arvados model attributes
name string Unparsed
description text Unparsed
job_uuid uuid The job that satisfies this job request.
Can be null if a suitable job has not yet been found or queued.
Assigned by the system: cannot be modified directly by clients.
If null, it can be changed by the system at any time.
If not null, it can be reset to null by a client if priority is zero.
mounts hash Objects to attach to the container's filesystem and stdin/stdout.
Keys starting with a forward slash indicate objects mounted in the container's filesystem.
Other keys are given special meanings here.
We use "stdin" instead of "/dev/stdin" because literally replacing /dev/stdin with a file would have a confusing effect on many unix programs. The stdin feature only affects the standard input of the first process started in the container; after that, the usual rules apply.		 
{
 "/input/foo":{
  "kind":"collection",
  "portable_data_hash":"d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e+0" 
 },
 "stdin":{
  "kind":"file",
  "uuid":"zzzzz-4zz18-yyyyyyyyyyyyyyy",
  "path":"/foo.txt" 
 },
 "stdout":{
  "kind":"output:object" 
 }
}
runtime_permissions hash Restrict the job's access to the outside world (apart from its explicitly stated inputs and output).
Each key is the name of a capability, like "internet" or "API" or "clock". The corresponding value is true (the capability must be available in the job's runtime environment) or false (must not). If a key is omitted, availability of the corresponding capability is acceptable but not necessary.		 This is a generalized version of "enforce purity restrictions": it is not a claim that the job will be pure. However, knowing which restrictions were in place can be helpful when reasoning about whether a given job was pure.
In the most basic implementation, no capabilities are defined, and the only acceptable value of this attribute is the empty hash.
(TC)This name isn't great, and conflicts with the "readable/writable" kind of permissions. Perhaps something along the lines of capabilities or interfaces?		 
{}
docker_image string Docker image repository and tag, docker image hash, collection UUID, or collection PDH.
environment hash environment variables and values that should be set in the container environment (docker run --env). This augments and (when conflicts exists) overrides environment variables given in the image's Dockerfile.
cwd string initial working directory, given as an absolute path (in the container) or a path relative to the WORKDIR given in the image's Dockerfile. The default is ".". 
"/tmp"
command array of strings Command to execute in the container. Default is the CMD given in the image's Dockerfile.
(TC)Possible to specify a pipe, like "echo foo | tr f b"? Any shell variables supported? Or do you just use ["sh","-c","echo $PATH | wc"] if you want a shell?
priority number Higher number means spend more resources (e.g., go ahead of other queued jobs, bring up more nodes).
Zero means a job should not be run. Clients are expected to submit JobRequests with zero priority in order to prevew the job that will be used to satisfy it.		 (TC)Do we need something more subtle than a single number?
(TC)What if a high priority job is waiting for a low priority job to finish?		 0, 1000.5, -1

"Job" schema

Attribute Type Description Discussion Examples
state, started_at, finished_at, log Same as current job
input, stdin, stdout, environment, initial_collection, cwd, command, runtime_debugging, git_checkout_dir, temp_dir, output_dir, keep_dir Copied from the relevant JobRequest(s) and made available to the job process.
output hash Arbitrary hash provided by the job process.
(PA)Changing the basic output type from a collection to a JSON object is important for native CWL support.
(TC)Need examples of how "output is one collection", "output is multiple collections", "output is collections plus other stuff(?)", and "output is other stuff without collections" are to be encoded.
pure boolean The job's output is thought to be dependent solely on its inputs (i.e., it is expected to produce identical output if repeated)
(TC)Is this merely an assertion by the submitter? Is the job itself expected to set or reset it? Does the system behave differently while running the job (e.g., different firewall rules, some APIs disabled)? [Under what conditions] is the system allowed to change it from true to false? Is null allowed, presumably signifying "not known"?		 null (?)
true
false
git_commit_sha1 string Full 40-character commit hash used to run the job. (TC)Should we store the tree hash as well? Or instead of the commit hash, if we prevent the job from seeing the git metadata, which would be good for reproducibility (consider a job that starts by doing "git checkout master" in its working directory).
(TC)Do we need to store git_repository here too? Presumably, the relevant git tree should be in the internal git repository as a prerequisite of Job creation. And if two repositories have the same commit/tree, it shouldn't matter which we pull it from when running the job.
docker_image_pdh string Portable data hash of a collection containing the docker image used to run the job. (TC) If docker image hashes can be verified efficiently, we can use the native docker image hash here instead of a collection PDH.
progress number A number between 0.0 and 1.0 describing the fraction of work done.
(TC)How does this relate to child tasks? E.g., is a job supposed to update this itself as its child tasks complete?
priority number Highest priority of all associated JobRequests

Mount types

The "mounts" hash is the primary mechanism for adding data to the container at runtime (beyond what is already in the container image).

Each value of the "mounts" hash is itself a hash, whose "kind" key determines the handler used to attach data to the container.

Mount type kind Expected keys Description Examples Discussion
Read-only collection collection
"portable_data_hash" or "uuid" can be provided.
At job startup, the target path will have the same directory structure as the given collection. Files in target path may be read-only. Even if the files/directories are writable, modifications will not be saved when the job ends.		 
{
 "kind":"collection",
 "uuid":"..." 
}
Read-only file file
Either "portable_data_hash" or "uuid" must be provided.
"path" must be provided, and must indicate a file in the given collection.
Behavior is identical to "Read-only collection" except that the target is a single file.		 
{
 "kind":"file",
 "uuid":"..." 
}
Output collection (initially empty) output:collection
None
At job startup, the target path will be empty. When the job ends, the content will be saved as the output of the job.		 
{
 "kind":"output:collection" 
}

(TC)Needs a "pre-populate with collection X" feature.
Output collection (initially empty) output:file
"name"
This is usable only for the "stdout" mount. The standard output of the container process will be written to a file in a new collection, and the resulting file (recorded as "{collection}/{path}") will be taken as the output of the job.		 
{
 "kind":"output:file" 
}
Output object output:object (?)
None
This is usable only for the "stdout" mount. The standard output of the container process will be parsed as JSON, and the resulting object will be taken as the output of the job.		 
{
 "kind":"output:object" 
}
Git tree git_tree
One of {"git-url", "repository_name", "uuid"} must be provided.
One of {"tree", "commit", "revisions"} must be provided.
At job startup, the target path will have the source tree indicated by the given revision. The .git metadata directory will not be available: typically the system will use git-archive rather than git-checkout to prepare the target directory.
If a value is given for "revisions", it will be resolved to a set of commits (as desribed in the "ranges" section of git-revisions(1)) and the job request will be satisfiable by any commit in that set.
If a value is given for "commit", it will be resolved to a single commit, and the tree resulting from that commit will be used.
If a value is given for "tree", the given tree will be used.
Note that multiple commit hashes can resolve to the same tree hash: e.g., identical patch with different committer/author/timestamp.		 
{
 "kind":"git_tree",
 "uuid":"zzzzz-s0uqq-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx",
 "commit":"master" 
}

{
 "kind":"git_tree",
 "uuid":"zzzzz-s0uqq-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx",
 "commit_range":"bugfix^..master" 
}

{
 "kind":"git_tree",
 "uuid":"zzzzz-s0uqq-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx",
 "tree":"bugfix^..master" 
}

(TC)Is the "tree" option here useful, or just unnecessary extra work? It seems to be the right way to test equivalence of two jobs, in any case.
Temporary directory tmp
None
At job startup, the target path will be empty. When the job finishes, the content will be discarded. This will be backed by a memory-based filesystem where possible.		 
{
 "kind":"tmp",
}

(TC)Should add a "max size" feature, to help memfs-backed implementations.

Permissions

Users own JobRequests but the system owns Jobs. Users get permission to read Jobs by virtue of linked JobRequests.

API methods

Changes from the usual REST APIs:

arvados.v1.job_requests.create and .update

These methods can fail when objects referenced in the "mounts" hash do not exist, or the acting user has insufficient permission on them.

arvados.v1.job_requests.update

The job_uuid attribute is special:
  • It cannot be changed from null to non-null by a regular client.
  • It cannot be changed from non-null to null by system processes.
  • It can be reset from non-null to null by the system during a client-initiated update transaction that modifies attributes other than state and priority.
Apart from job_uuid, updates are restricted by the current state of the job request.
  • When state="Preview", all attributes can be updated.
  • When state="Request", only priority and state can be updated.
  • When state="Done", no attributes can be updated.
state cannot be null. The following state transitions are the only ones permitted.
  • Preview → Request
  • Preview → Done
  • Request → Done

arvados.v1.jobs.create and .update

These methods are not callable except by system processes.

arvados.v1.jobs.progress

This method permits specific types of updates while a job is running: update progress, record success/failure.

Q: [How] can a client submitting job B indicate it shouldn't run unless/until job A succeeds?

Debugging

Q: Need any infrastructure debug-logging controls in this API?

Q: Need any job debug-logging controls in this API? Or just use environment vars?

Scheduling and running jobs

Q: If two users submit identical pure jobs and ask to reuse existing jobs, whose token does the job get to use?
  • Should pure jobs be run as a pseudo-user that is given read access to the relevant objects for the duration of the job? (This would make it safer to share jobs -- see #5823)
Q: If two users submit identical pure jobs with different priority, which priority is used?
  • Choices include "whichever is greater" and "sum".

Q: If two users submit identical pure jobs and one cancels -- or one user submits two identical jobs and cancels one -- does the work stop, or continue? What do the job records look like after this?

Updated by Tom Clegg almost 9 years ago · 8 revisions